Review: The Village Killer (DI Barton #7) by Ross Greenwood

      


Print Length: 401 pages
Publisher:  Boldwood Books (November 1, 2024)

From Goodreads.com: Inspector Barton has spent three years behind a desk. His developmental role is ending, and he must decide what’s next. At fifty-years-old, Barton suspects the next position will be his last.

When an opportunity arises to return to Major Crimes, he jumps at it. He is soon involved in a troubling case. A woman’s life is in peril, and a child has vanished. It’s challenges like these he came back for, but then a man dies, and the pressure builds.

Barton finds himself embroiled in an investigation like no other. Most murders boil down to money or sex, but in the sleepy village of Castor, it seems the motivation is obsession, and there’s nothing more deadly than that.

                                                         *******************


My Rating: 3 stars out of 5

While I enjoyed this book quite a bit, there was just something missing that I can't quite put my finger on. 

On the surface, it had all of the usual earmarks not only of a good story, but of a story by this author. There was an interesting plot that consisted of several seemingly unconnected storylines, some shady characters that had you consistently questioning their potential roles in what was going on, while also containing the usual balance between Barton the tireless leader, and Barton the husband and father.

Maybe the problem for me was that they were a little too interconnected. I mean you have Poppy, the “missing fourteen-year-old” whose mother just happens to be friends with the woman who was almost run down and whose uncle is suspected in a different case. And sure, I get these things sometimes happen, but it was just a little too neat for me. Especially when you take into consideration the way that Poppy dressed and acted. Yes, I am aware of the fact that it is an actual condition (I did read the author’s notes at the end), but she didn’t seem crucial to the plot at all, and in fact it was more than a little disturbing to find out just what she had been up to (and a little unfathomable that she was able to use someone else’s photo identification as her own).

I also felt as though there were some chapters that could have been removed altogether, and it would not have changed the plot at all. To bring Poppy back into it, what was the purpose of Barton running into her outside of a grocery store after the investigations had been wrapped? She was still the same belligerent child that she had been, and it was obvious that she had learned nothing from what had happened. In my opinion, it simply wasn’t needed.

There were also a couple of instances where it would seem the author forgot details moments after they happened. In one case, there was a whole conversation between Robert and Barton as they drove to the police station, but as soon as their interview there wraps up, the author says that Robert had taken a taxi to the station as he wasn’t sure of the parking situation. This threw me to the point I had to go back and make sure the scene with them talking had in fact taken place.

I will say, I enjoyed some of the witty comments that were thrown into this one, such as Barton’s wife telling him that he would be fine to accept the position as the eldest had moved out, their youngest was in school and their teenaged daughter would be “circling the roof on her broomstick for the next few years.” As a mom who has raised teenaged daughters, I could not think of a more fitting description.

All things considered, while this wasn’t my favorite book in the series, it still holds up well on its own, and I will continue to read more from this author in the future. 

DISCLAIMER: I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not affected my review in any way. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are 100% my own.
                                                                                          


Post a Comment

0 Comments